ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LTD filed this 20-F on 07/26/2022
ALIBABA GROUP HOLDING LTD - 20-F - 20220726 - SECURITY_OWNERS
advising the board periodically with regards to significant developments in corporate governance law and practices as well as our compliance with applicable laws and regulations, and making recommendations to the board on corporate governance matters.

Sustainability Committee

Our sustainability committee currently consists of Jerry Yang, Walter Kwauk, Joe Tsai and Maggie Wu. Mr. Yang is the chairman of our sustainability committee.

Our sustainability committee is responsible for, among other things:

assisting the board in identifying and evaluating the company’s ESG opportunities and risks;
overseeing an evaluating the implementation and performance of ESG initiatives and projects; and
advising the board on ESG-related legal, regulatory and compliance developments and public policy trends.

Committee Observer

In accordance with our Articles and the voting agreement that we entered into with SoftBank and the other parties thereto, we have agreed that the director nominated by SoftBank is entitled to receive notices and materials for all meetings of our committees and to join as an observer in meetings of the audit committee, the compensation committee, the nominating and corporate governance committee and/or our other board committees we may establish upon notice to the relevant committee.

D.

Employees

As of March 31, 2020, 2021 and 2022, we had a total of 117,600, 251,462 and 254,941 full-time employees, respectively. The increase in our employees was primarily due to our recent acquisitions and consolidation of certain businesses, as well as our organic business growth. A substantial majority of our employees are based in China.

We believe that we have a good working relationship with our employees and we have not experienced any significant labor disputes.

E.

Share Ownership

For information regarding the share ownership of our directors and officers, see “Item 7. Major Shareholders and Related Party Transactions — A. Major Shareholders.” For information as to stock options granted to our directors, executive officers and other employees, see “Item 6. Directors, Senior Management and Employees — B. Compensation — Equity Incentive Plans.”

ITEM 7.    MAJOR SHAREHOLDERS AND RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS

A.   Major Shareholders

The following table sets forth information with respect to beneficial ownership of our ordinary shares as of July 15, 2022, except otherwise noted, by:

each of our directors and executive officers;
our directors and executive officers as a group; and
each person known to us to beneficially own 5% or more of our ordinary shares.

182

Beneficial ownership is determined in accordance with the rules and regulations of the SEC and includes the power to direct the voting or the disposition of the securities or to receive the economic benefit of the ownership of the securities. In computing the number of shares beneficially owned by a person and the percentage ownership of that person, we have included Shares underlying the ADSs and Shares in CCASS held by the person. We have also included Shares that the person has the right to acquire within 60 days of this annual report, including through the vesting of RSUs and the exercise of any option. These Shares, however, are not included in the computation of the percentage ownership of any other person. The calculations of percentage ownership in the table below are based on 21,185,107,544 ordinary shares (equivalent to 2,648,138,443 ADSs) outstanding as of July 15, 2022.

    

    

    

Beneficial ownership

Beneficial ownership

Name

 

(Ordinary shares)

(ADSs)(3)

Percent

Directors and Executive Officers:

 

  

 

  

 

  

Daniel Yong ZHANG

*

*

*

Joseph C. TSAI(1)

 

305,526,416

 

38,190,802

 

1.4%

J. Michael EVANS

 

*

 

*

 

*

Maggie Wei WU

 

*

 

*

 

*

Kabir MISRA

 

*

 

*

 

*

Chee Hwa TUNG

 

*

 

*

 

*

Walter Teh Ming KWAUK

 

*

 

*

 

*

Jerry YANG

 

*

 

*

 

*

Wan Ling MARTELLO

 

*

 

*

 

*

Weijian SHAN

*

*

*

Toby Hong XU

*

*

*

Judy Wenhong TONG

 

*

 

*

 

*

Li CHENG

 

*

 

*

 

*

Sara Siying YU

*

*

*

Jessie Junfang ZHENG

 

*

 

*

 

*

Trudy Shan DAI

*

*

*

All directors and executive officers as a group

 

441,562,978

 

55,195,372

 

2.1%

Greater than 5% Beneficial Owners:

SoftBank(2)

 

5,067,408,616

 

633,426,077

 

23.9%

Notes:

*

This person beneficially owns less than 1% of our outstanding ordinary shares.

(1)Represents (i) 294,400 ordinary shares held directly by Joe Tsai, (ii) 20,307,176 ordinary shares held by Joe and Clara Tsai Foundation Limited, a company incorporated under the law of the Island of Guernsey with its registered address at Helvetia Court, South Esplanade, St. Peter Port, Guernsey GY1 4EE, that has granted Joe Tsai a revocable proxy over these shares and which is wholly-owned by Joe and Clara Tsai Foundation, (iii) 147,385,672 ordinary shares held by Parufam Limited, a Bahamas corporation with its registered address at Suite 200B, 2nd Floor, Centre of Commerce, One Bay Street, P.O. Box N 3944, Nassau, Bahamas, and over which, Joe Tsai, as a director of Parufam Limited, has been delegated sole voting and disposition power and (iv) 137,539,168 ordinary shares held by PMH Holding Limited, a British Virgin Islands corporation with its registered address at Trident Chambers, P.O. Box 146, Road Town, Tortola, British Virgin Islands, and over which, Joe Tsai, as sole director of PMH Holding Limited, has voting and dispositive power. Excludes shares held by SoftBank representing SoftBank’s share ownership in excess of 30% of our outstanding ordinary shares as of the most recent record date with respect to any shareholders action, over which Joe Tsai has voting power pursuant to the amended and restated voting agreement that we, Joe Tsai and SoftBank have entered into as described in “Item 7. Major Shareholders and Related Party Transactions — B. Related Party Transactions — Transactions and Agreements with SoftBank — Amended Voting Agreement.” Joe Tsai does not have any pecuniary interests in the 20,307,176 ordinary shares held by Joe and Clara Tsai Foundation Limited. Joe Tsai’s business address is 26/F Tower One, Times Square, 1 Matheson Street, Causeway Bay, Hong Kong S.A.R., the People’s Republic of China.
(2)Represents ordinary shares owned directly and indirectly by SoftBank Group Corp., with its registered office at 1-7-1, Kaigan, Minato-Ku, Tokyo, 105-7537, Japan. A portion of the ordinary shares are beneficially owned via direct or indirect subsidiaries of SoftBank Group Corp. As of July 15, 2022, none of the subsidiaries of SoftBank Group Corp. holding our ordinary shares beneficially owned more than 5% of our outstanding ordinary shares, with the exception of Skywalk Finance GK, with its registered office at 1-7-1, Kaigan, Minato-Ku, Tokyo, 105-7537, Japan, which beneficially owned 1,360,000,000, or 6.4% of our outstanding ordinary shares. According to public disclosure by SoftBank, SoftBank has entered into forward contracts and margin loans using a portion of our shares.
(3)Each ADS represents eight ordinary shares.

We have one class of ordinary shares, and each holder of our ordinary shares is entitled to one vote per share.

183

As of July 15, 2022, 21,185,107,544 of our ordinary shares (equivalent to 2,648,138,443 ADSs) were outstanding. To our knowledge, 7,184,171,019 ordinary shares (equivalent to 898,021,377 ADSs), representing approximately 34% of our total outstanding shares, were held by 187 record shareholders with registered addresses in the United States, including brokers and banks that hold securities in street name on behalf of their customers. We are not aware of any arrangement that may at a subsequent date, result in a change of control of our company.

B.

Related Party Transactions

Our Related Party Transaction Policy

In order to prevent risks of conflicts of interest or the appearance of conflicts of interest, all of our directors and employees are subject to our code of business conduct and other policies which require, among other things, that any potential transaction between us and an employee or director, their relatives and closely connected persons and certain entities in which they, their relatives or closely connected persons have an interest be approved in writing by an appropriate supervisor or compliance officer.

We have also adopted a related party transaction policy to which all of our directors, senior management and other key management personnel, all close family members (as defined in the policy) of the foregoing individuals, Ant Group and its subsidiaries as well as the Alibaba Partnership and certain other related entities are subject. Related party transactions defined under this policy, as required by Form 20-F, include transactions with our directors, senior management and major shareholders and their affiliates, as well as transactions with parties that do not pose risks of conflicts of interest, such as transactions with our investee companies that are not otherwise affiliated with any of the foregoing individuals. This policy is intended to supplement the procedures set forth in our code of business conduct and our other corporate governance policies and does not exempt any person from more restrictive provisions that may exist in our existing procedures and policies.

This related party transaction policy provides, among other things, that, unless otherwise pre-approved by our board of directors:

each related party transaction, and any material amendment or modification to a related party transaction, shall be adequately disclosed to, and reviewed and approved or ratified by, our audit committee or any committee composed solely of disinterested independent directors or by the disinterested members of such committee; and
any employment relationship or similar transaction involving our directors or senior management and any related compensation shall be approved by the disinterested members of our compensation committee or recommended by the disinterested members of the compensation committee to our board for its approval.

Our related party transaction policy, code of business conduct and our other corporate governance policies are subject to periodic review and revision by our board.

Summary of Major Related Party Transactions

We have entered into various commercial arrangements with certain of our investees, Ant Group and its affiliates, pursuant to which we receive and provide certain services to these parties. See “— Commercial Arrangements with Investees and Ant Group and Its Affiliates.” In addition, as disclosed in greater detail in the following paragraphs, we have entered into certain major related party transactions in fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, which are summarized in the table below.

Related Party

    

Transaction Description

 

SoftBank

Amended voting agreement among us, Joe Tsai and SoftBank, and, solely for limited purposes, Jack Ma, which, among others, provides that SoftBank and Joe Tsai will vote their shares in favor of the Alibaba Partnership director nominees, and provides SoftBank with the right to nominate a director.

Various investments involving SoftBank.

Ant Group and its affiliates

The SAPA, which was amended in 2018, 2019, 2020 and 2022, pursuant to which we received a 33% equity interest in Ant Group, and which sets forth, among other things, our rights in Ant Group.

The Alipay commercial agreement, pursuant to which Alipay provides payment and escrow services to us.

184

Related Party

    

Transaction Description

 

The 2014 IPLA, an amendment to which was subsequently entered into in 2019 upon our receipt of the 33% equity interest in Ant Group, or the Amended IPLA, provides that we and our subsidiaries license to Ant Group and/or its subsidiaries certain intellectual property rights and provide various software technology services, and, prior to our receipt of the 33% equity interest in Ant Group, Ant Group paid us profit share payments; pursuant to the SAPA, a cross-license agreement was entered into in September 2019 upon our receipt of the 33% equity interest in Ant Group.

We and Ant Group cooperate with each other with respect to the enforcement of each other’s rights and the provision of certain financial services to our customers and merchants in connection with the SME loan business.

We granted Ant Group a license for it to continue to use certain trademarks and domain names.

Various investments involving Ant Group.

We have granted share-based awards to employees of Ant Group; Junhan, a major equity holder of Ant Group, and Ant Group have granted share-based awards to our employees. We, Junhan and Ant Group agreed to settle with each other the cost associated with certain share-based awards granted to each other’s employees upon vesting.

Jack Ma, Joe Tsai, and J. Michael Evans

We agreed to assume the cost of maintenance, crew and operation of personal aircraft of certain directors and officers where the cost is allocated for business purposes.

Investment funds affiliated with Jack Ma

Various investments involving the Yunfeng Funds, investment funds affiliated with Jack Ma.

Jack Ma

Jack Ma, formerly one of our directors made certain commitments to us relating to his interest in Ant Group, the Yunfeng Funds and other entities.

Investees

We extended loans to and provided a guarantee for certain of our investees.

We have made co-investments with certain of our investees.

Variable interest entities and variable interest entity equity holders

We operate certain of our businesses in China through contractual arrangements between our relevant subsidiaries, the variable interest entities and variable interest entity equity holders.

Directors and executive officers

We entered into indemnification agreements with our directors and executive officers.

We entered into employment agreements with our directors and executive officers.

We grant equity incentive awards to our directors and executive officers.

185

Commercial Arrangements with Investees and Ant Group and Its Affiliates

The following table summarizes the services fees paid to Ant Group and its affiliates in fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022.

 

Year Ended March 31,

 

 

2020

 

2021

 

2022

Related Party

    

Transaction

    

RMB

    

RMB

    

RMB

    

US$

 

(in millions)

Ant Group and its affiliates

 

Payment processing and escrow services fee

 

8,723

 

10,598

 

11,824

 

1,865

 

Administrative and support services

 

124

 

218

 

161

 

25

 

Marketplace software technology services fee and others(1)

 

2,619

 

4,291

 

3,381

 

533

Note:

(1)Marketplace software technology services fee and others primarily relates to marketing support services in connection with our retail marketplaces.

Certain of our investees have entered into commercial arrangements with us in connection with certain logistics services they provide to us. In fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, we incurred costs and expenses of RMB8,265 million, RMB11,068 million and RMB13,120 million (US$2,070 million), respectively, for these logistics services. In fiscal year 2022, these costs and expenses accounted for 1.7% of our costs and expenses.

Certain of our investees have also entered into commercial arrangements with us in connection with certain marketing services they provide to our business. In fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, we incurred costs and expenses of RMB1,146 million, RMB1,394 million and RMB976 million (US$154 million), respectively, for these marketing services. In fiscal year 2022, these costs and expenses accounted for 0.1% of our costs and expenses.

Other than the foregoing, the aggregate service fees we paid to other related parties accounted for less than 1% of total costs and expenses in each of fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022.

The following table summarizes the services fees received from Ant Group and its affiliates in fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022.

 

Year Ended March 31,

 

 

2020

 

2021

 

2022

Related Party

    

Transaction

    

RMB

    

RMB

    

RMB

    

US$

 

(in millions)

Ant Group

 

Software technology services fee and license fee(1)

 

3,835

 

 

 

Ant Group and its affiliates

 

Annual fee for SME loan business(2)

 

954

 

954

 

708

 

112

 

Administrative and support services

 

1,224

 

1,208

 

1,165

 

184

 

Cloud services fee

 

1,872

 

3,916

 

5,536

 

873

 

Marketplace software technology services fee and others

 

2,075

 

2,427

 

2,358

 

372

Notes:

(1)Terminated in September 2019 following our receipt of a 33% equity interest in Ant Group.
(2)Pursuant to our agreement with Ant Group, we received these annual fees for a term of seven years, commencing in 2015 and ending in 2021.

186

We have entered into commercial arrangements with certain of our investees related to logistics services. In fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, we recognized revenue of RMB1,400 million, RMB1,732 million and RMB1,728 million (US$273 million), respectively, in connection with these logistics services. In fiscal year 2022, this revenue accounted for 0.2% of our revenue.

We have also entered into commercial arrangements with certain of our investees related to cloud services. In fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, we recognized revenue of RMB1,548 million, RMB2,411 million and RMB1,826 million (US$288 million), respectively, for these cloud services. In fiscal year 2022, this revenue accounted for 0.2 % of our revenue.

Other than the related party transactions summarized above, the aggregate payments we received from other related parties accounted for less than 1% of total revenue in each of the fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022.

Transactions and Agreements with SoftBank

Amended Voting Agreement

We entered into a voting agreement, which was amended and restated in December 2021, or the amended voting agreement. The amended voting agreement, by and among us, Joe Tsai and SoftBank, and, solely for limited purposes, Jack Ma, provides SoftBank with the right to nominate one director to our board of directors who will, subject to certain conditions, have the right to receive notices and materials for all meetings of our committees and to join these meetings as an observer, which rights are also reflected in our Memorandum and Articles of Association. These nomination rights will terminate when SoftBank’s shareholding declines below 15% of our outstanding shares. The voting agreement also contains provisions to the effect that:

SoftBank agrees to:
vote its shares in favor of the election of the Alibaba Partnership’s director nominees at each annual general shareholders meeting until SoftBank’s shareholding declines below 15% of our outstanding shares, and
grant the voting power of any portion of its shareholdings exceeding 30% of our outstanding ordinary shares to Joe Tsai by proxy (although on December 31, 2021, SoftBank owned less than 30% of our outstanding ordinary shares and, therefore, Joe Tsai did not have voting power over any ordinary shares held by SoftBank);
Joe Tsai will vote his shares and any other shares over which he holds voting rights in favor of the election of the SoftBank director nominee at each annual general shareholders meeting in which the SoftBank nominee stands for election until SoftBank’s shareholding declines below 15% of our outstanding ordinary shares;
each party to the voting agreement will use its commercially reasonable efforts to cause any other person with whom it jointly files a statement (or an amendment to a statement) on Schedule 13D or Schedule 13G pursuant to the U.S. Exchange Act to become a party to the voting agreement and vote its shares in favor of SoftBank’s and the Alibaba Partnership’s director nominees pursuant to the foregoing; and
SoftBank will receive certain information rights in connection with the preparation of their financial statements.

SoftBank’s proxy obligations described above shall (a) not apply in respect of any proposal submitted to our shareholders that may result in an issuance of shares or other equity interests of us, including securities exchangeable or convertible into shares, that would increase the amount of our then-outstanding shares by 3% or more and (b) terminate when Jack Ma owns less than 1% of our outstanding shares on a fully diluted basis or if we materially breach the voting agreement.

Investments Involving SoftBank

We have invested in businesses in which SoftBank or one or more of its affiliates is a shareholder or co-invested with SoftBank or one or more of its affiliates in other businesses. SoftBank has also invested in businesses in which we or our controlled entities are shareholders. We may continue to co-invest with SoftBank, invest in businesses in which SoftBank is already an existing investor, and may also bring SoftBank as an investor into new businesses or businesses in which we are an existing investor.

187

Agreements and Transactions Related to Ant Group and Its Subsidiaries

Ownership of Ant Group and Alipay

We originally established Alipay in December 2004 to operate our payment services business. In June 2010, the PBOC issued new regulations that required non-bank payment companies to obtain a license in order to operate in China. These regulations provided specific guidelines for license applications only for domestic PRC-owned entities. These regulations stipulated that, in order for any foreign-invested payment company to obtain a license, the scope of business, the qualifications of any foreign investor and any level of foreign ownership would be subject to future regulations to be issued, which in addition would require approval by the State Council of the PRC. Furthermore, these regulations required that any payment company that failed to obtain a license must cease operations by September 1, 2011. Although Alipay was prepared to submit its license application in early 2011, at that time the PBOC had not issued any guidelines applicable to license applications for foreign-invested payment companies. In light of the uncertainties relating to the license qualification and application process for a foreign-invested payment company, our management determined that it was necessary to restructure Alipay as a company wholly-owned by PRC citizens in order to avail Alipay of the specific licensing guidelines applicable only to domestic PRC-owned entities. Accordingly, we divested all of our interest in and control over Alipay in 2011, which resulted in deconsolidation of Alipay from our financial statements. This action enabled Alipay to obtain a payment business license in May 2011 without delay and without any detrimental impact to our China retail marketplaces or to Alipay.

Following the divestment of our interest in and control over Alipay, effective in the first calendar quarter of 2011, the ownership structure of Alipay’s parent entity, Ant Group, was changed so that Jack Ma held a substantial majority of the equity ownership interest in Ant Group. The ownership structure of Ant Group subsequently was further restructured. Ant Group also completed several rounds of equity financing. In September 2019, we received a newly issued 33% equity interest in Ant Group following the satisfaction of the closing conditions set forth in the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019. As of March 31, 2022, Junhan and Junao held more than 50% of Ant Group’s equity interest, we held 33% and other shareholders held the remaining equity interest. The general partner of Junhan and Junao is an entity that was previously wholly-owned by Jack Ma. In August 2020, Jack Ma transferred 66% of the equity interest in such general partner entity but retained control over the equity interests in Ant Group held by Junhan and Junao. Through an agreement with the transferees as well as the articles of association of the general partner entity, Jack Ma has control over resolutions passed at general meetings of the general partner entity that relate to the exercise of rights by Junhan and Junao as shareholders of Ant Group.

Economic interests of Ant Group through Junhan are owned by Jack Ma, Simon Xie and other employees of us and Ant Group and its affiliates and investee companies. These economic interests are in the form of limited partnership interests and interests similar to share appreciation rights tied to potential appreciation in the value of Ant Group. The economic interests in Junao are held in the form of limited partnership interests by certain members of the Alibaba Partnership.

We understand that it is the intention of the shareholders of Ant Group that:

Jack Ma’s direct and indirect economic interest in Ant Group (for the avoidance of doubt, other than the equity stake in Ant Group held by our company) will be reduced over time to a percentage that does not exceed his and his affiliates’ interest in our company as of the time immediately prior to the completion of our initial public offering (the percentage of our ordinary shares Jack Ma and his affiliates beneficially owned immediately prior to the completion of our initial public offering was 8.8%) and that this reduction will be caused in a manner by which neither Jack Ma nor any of his affiliates would receive any economic benefit thereby. See “— Commitments of Jack Ma to Alibaba Group” below. We have been informed by Ant Group that the proposed reduction of Jack Ma’s economic interest is expected to be accomplished through a combination of future share-based awards to employees and dilutive issuances of equity in Ant Group, among others;
from time to time, additional economic interests in Ant Group in the form of interests similar to share appreciation rights issued by Junhan will be transferred to employees of Ant Group and our employees; and
Ant Group may raise equity capital from investors in the future in order to finance its business expansion, with the effect that the shareholding of Junao and Junhan in Ant Group will be reduced through dilution (the amount of dilution would depend on future valuations and the amount of equity capital to be raised).

188

Our Commercial Arrangements with Ant Group and Alipay

After the divestment of our interest in and control over Alipay, we entered into a framework agreement in July 2011, or the 2011 framework agreement, with SoftBank, Altaba, Alipay, Ant Group, Jack Ma and Joe Tsai and certain of their affiliates. At the same time, we also entered into various implementation agreements that included a commercial agreement, or the Alipay commercial agreement, an intellectual property license and software technology service agreement, or the 2011 IPLA, and a shared services agreement, which together governed our financial and commercial relationships with Ant Group and Alipay.

Restructuring of Our Relationship with Ant Group and Alipay, 2019 Equity Issuance, and Related Amendments

On August 12, 2014, we entered into a share and asset purchase agreement, which we refer to as the SAPA, and entered into or amended certain ancillary agreements including an amendment and restatement of the 2011 IPLA, or the 2014 IPLA. Pursuant to these agreements, we restructured our relationships with Ant Group and Alipay and terminated the 2011 framework agreement. On February 1, 2018, we amended both the SAPA and the Alipay commercial agreement, and agreed with Ant Group and certain other parties on forms of certain ancillary agreements. On September 23, 2019, we further amended the SAPA. The relevant amendments were entered into or agreed to facilitate our acquisition of a 33% equity interest in Ant Group. On August 24, 2020, we further amended the SAPA, the Alipay commercial agreement and certain other agreements, referred to as the 2020 Amendments. The 2020 Amendments were made primarily to facilitate Ant Group’s planned IPO on the Science and Technology Innovation Board of the Shanghai Stock Exchange and on the Main Board of the Hong Kong Stock Exchange.

On July 25, 2022, we and Ant Group further amended the SAPA and the Alipay commercial agreement (such further amendments, the “2022 Amendments”), with certain amendments to take effect on August 13, 2022. The 2022 Amendments were made primarily to improve our ability to maximize our competitive advantage, enhance the economic benefit from our equity interest in Ant Group and help us better manage related party and other risks arising from changes in the regulatory and operational environment.

Apart from the 2018, 2019, 2020 and 2022 amendments to our agreements with Ant Group described below, the key terms of our agreements with Ant Group and Alipay from the 2014 restructuring remain substantially unchanged.

Sale of SME Loan Business and Certain Other Assets

Pursuant to the SAPA, we sold certain securities and assets primarily relating to our SME loan business and other related services to Ant Group in February 2015. In addition, pursuant to software system use and service agreements relating to the know-how and related intellectual property that we agreed to sell together with the SME loan business and related services, we received annual fees for a term of seven years, commencing in 2015 and ending in 2021. These fees, which were recognized as other revenue, were determined as follows: for calendar years 2015 to 2017, the entities operating the SME loan business paid an annual fee equal to 2.5% of the average daily balance of the SME loans provided by these entities, and in calendar years 2018 to 2021, these entities paid an annual fee equal to the amount of the fees paid in calendar year 2017. In fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, the annual fees we received from Ant Group and its affiliates in connection with the SME loan business amounted to RMB954 million, RMB954 million and RMB708 million (US$112 million), respectively.

For regulatory reasons, we retained approximately RMB1,225 million of the existing SME loan portfolio upon the completion of the transfer of the SME loan business. These loans have been repaid. We do not intend to conduct any new SME loan business going forward.

Issuance of Equity Interest

In September 2019, following the satisfaction of the closing conditions, we received through an onshore PRC subsidiary the issuance of a 33% equity interest in Ant Group pursuant to the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, or the Issuance. We believe that the acquisition of the 33% equity interest in Ant Group has strengthened our strategic relationship pursuant to the series of agreements initially reached with Ant Group in 2014.

Pursuant to the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, the consideration we paid to receive the newly issued 33% equity interest in Ant Group was fully funded by payments from Ant Group and its subsidiaries to us in consideration for certain intellectual property and assets that we transferred under the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019.

189

In connection with the receipt of the Issuance, we entered into a cross license agreement with Ant Group providing for a license by each of Ant Group and us to each other of certain patents, trademarks, software and other technologies (including but not limited to patents and software transferred at the Issuance closing). The cross license agreement also contains provisions relating to cooperation and coordination between Ant Group and us on various intellectual property matters, including prosecution, enforcement, acquisition, and joint defense arrangements, among other matters.

Upon closing of the Issuance, we entered into the previously agreed form of amendment and restatement of the 2014 IPLA, or the Amended IPLA, and the profit share payment arrangement under the 2014 IPLA automatically terminated. For more information, see “— Alipay Intellectual Property License and Software Technology Services Agreement” below.

Financial and Accounting Treatment upon Issuance of Equity Interest in Ant Group

There was no material operational and economic impact on us as a result of our receipt of the 33% equity interest in Ant Group in 2019, but we changed our accounting for our relationship with Ant Group as a result of the Issuance. Upon the Issuance, and our transfer of certain intellectual property to Ant Group and its subsidiaries, the profit share arrangement under the 2014 IPLA was terminated. For the years ended March 31, 2020, 2021 and 2022, the profit share payments recorded in “Other income, net” in our consolidated income statements amounted to RMB3,835 million, nil and nil, respectively. Following our receipt of the Issuance, we no longer received any profit share payments from Ant Group. Following the Issuance, we accounted for our equity interest in Ant Group under the equity method and recorded it in “Investment in equity method investees” on our consolidated balance sheet. In fiscal year 2020, we recognized a one-time gain of RMB71.6 billion in relation to the receipt of the 33% equity interest in Ant Group. Subsequent to the Issuance, we record our proportionate share of results of Ant Group in “Share of results of equity method investees” in our consolidated income statements on a one quarter in-arrears basis.

Regulatory Unwind

Prior to the 2020 Amendments, the SAPA as amended in 2018 and 2019, provided that, if a relevant governmental authority prohibits us from owning all or a portion of our equity interest in Ant Group after the equity issuance has occurred through enactment of a law, rule or regulation, or explicitly requires Ant Group to redeem this equity interest, and the prohibition or request is not subject to appeal and cannot otherwise be resolved, then to the extent necessary, Ant Group will redeem the equity interest; the related intellectual property and asset transfers, and ancillary transactions under the SAPA will be unwound; and the terms of the SAPA, the 2014 IPLA, and other related agreements will be restored, including the prior profit share payments and liquidity event payment (which would be payable to us in the event of a qualified IPO of Ant Group or Alipay, in an amount equal to 37.5% of the equity value of Ant Group as a whole, immediately prior to the qualified IPO). If there is a partial unwind where we retain a portion of our equity interest in Ant Group, but less than the full 33%, then pursuant to the terms of the SAPA and the 2014 IPLA, the prior profit share payment arrangement and liquidity event payment amount will be proportionately reduced based on the amount of equity interest retained by us. Pursuant to the 2020 Amendments, these provisions would terminate upon the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group. However, pursuant to the 2020 Amendments and the 2022 Amendments, if a qualified IPO of Ant Group has not been completed within the prescribed period of time, the foregoing rights will no longer be subject to termination upon the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group.

In 2011, Jack Ma and Joe Tsai contributed 280,000,000 and 120,000,000 of our Shares, respectively, after having accounted for the Share Split, held by them to APN Ltd. (“APN”), a vehicle they established to hold these shares. Prior to June 2, 2022, the shares of APN, as well as the 400,000,000 Shares, after having accounted for the Share Split, held by APN, were pledged to us to secure certain obligations of Ant Group under the SAPA and the Alipay commercial agreement, as well as the direct liability of APN for up to US$500 million of the liquidity event payment if any liquidity event payment becomes due. On June 2, 2022, we agreed with Jack Ma, Joe Tsai and APN to terminate the pledges in relation to the shares of APN and the 400,000,000 Shares, in consideration of personal guarantees provided to us by Jack Ma and Joe Tsai in connection with Ant Group’s remaining contingent payment obligations to us. We believe this transaction reasonably reflects the reduction in Ant Group’s contingent payment obligations to us since 2011 when the pledges were first created, the valuation of which was conducted with help from an independent financial advisor, and the increased financial strength and creditworthiness of Ant Group.

190

Pre-emptive Rights

Following our receipt of equity interest in Ant Group, we have pre-emptive rights to participate in other issuances of equity securities by Ant Group and certain of its affiliates prior to a qualified IPO of Ant Group. These pre-emptive rights entitle us to maintain the equity ownership percentage we hold in Ant Group immediately prior to any such issuances. In connection with our exercise of our pre-emptive rights we are also entitled to receive certain payments from Ant Group, effectively funding our subscription for these additional equity interests, up to a value of US$1.5 billion, subject to certain adjustments, or the pre-emptive rights funded payments. In addition to these pre-emptive rights and the pre-emptive rights funded payments, under the SAPA (as amended), in certain circumstances we are permitted to exercise pre-emptive rights through an alternative arrangement that will further protect us from dilution.

Certain Restrictions on the Transfer of Ant Group Equity Interests

Under the SAPA (as amended), certain parties thereto, including us in some cases, are subject to restrictions on the transfer of equity interests in Ant Group, including:

following our receipt of the Issuance and until the earlier of the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group or the termination of the independent director rights provided in the SAPA, without the prior written consent of our company, none of Jack Ma, Joe Tsai (if he holds any equity interest at that time), Junao, Junhan or Ant Group may knowingly transfer any equity in Ant Group to a third-party who would thereby acquire more than 50% of the voting or economic rights in, or assets of, Ant Group; and
following our receipt of the Issuance and until the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group, any transfer of equity interests in Ant Group by Junao or Junhan, on the one hand, or our company, on the other hand, will be subject to a right of first refusal by the other party.

Non-competition Undertakings

Under the SAPA, subject to certain limitations and unless both parties agree, Ant Group may not engage in any business conducted by us from time to time or logical extensions thereof, and we are restricted from engaging in specified business activities within the scope of business of Ant Group, including the provision and distribution of credit and insurance, the provision of investment management and banking services, payment transaction processing and payment clearing services for third parties, leasing, lease financing and related services, trading, dealing and brokerage with respect to foreign exchange and financial instruments, distribution of securities, commodities, funds, derivatives and other financial products and the provision of credit ratings, credit profiles and credit reports. Each party may, however, make passive investments in competing businesses below specified thresholds, in some cases after offering the investment opportunity to the other party. The 2020 Amendments allow Ant Group to engage in the sale and placement of advertisements by financial institutions solely in connection with financial services on publicly available mobile applications and end-user interfaces majority-owned and operated by Ant Group, an activity that falls within the scope of our business but which Ant Group is permitted to engage in as an exception to the non-compete provisions, subject to certain qualifications. Pursuant to the 2022 Amendments, we have agreed to expand Ant Group’s ability to engage in such sale and placement of advertisements on publicly available mobile applications and end-user interfaces majority-owned and operated by Ant Group. We have also agreed to permit Ant Group to provide technology services in facilitation of the operations of any payment or financial services business to financial institutions and merchants using Ant Group’s payment services, except that Ant Group may not provide any IaaS-related cloud services, and we are allowed to provide services and products relating to payment accounts outside of Mainland China that Ant Group is unable to provide to us or our customers and to provide and distribute credit and insurance in cooperation with financial services business operators to facilitate businesses on our platforms, among other things.

191

Corporate Governance Provisions

The SAPA, as amended, provides that we and Ant Group will recommend one independent nominee who, subject to the vetting by the nomination and remuneration committee of the board of Ant Group, to the extent required by such committee’s charter (subject to any amendments required by any applicable law or requested by any applicable governmental authority), and subject further to the vetting by applicable governmental authorities, as required by applicable law, will be nominated as a member of its board and serve on the board’s audit committee, and Jack Ma, Joe Tsai (in case he holds any equity interest in Ant Group), Junhan and Junao will agree to vote the equity interests in Ant Group controlled by them in favor of the nomination. If this independent director resigns or the director’s seat otherwise becomes vacant, so long as SoftBank owns at least 20% of our outstanding ordinary shares, and certain other conditions are satisfied, SoftBank and Jack Ma, acting jointly, will select on our behalf the individual to be designated as a replacement director, subject to the approval of the Independent Committee. We are not permitted to approve certain actions to be taken under the SAPA (as amended) and related agreements before we obtain the consent from the Independent Committee.

Upon the Issuance in September 2019, we nominated two of our officers who have been elected to the board of Ant Group pursuant to our rights under the SAPA (as amended).

In each case, these director nomination rights will continue unless we cease to own a certain amount of our post-issuance equity interests in Ant Group, or upon the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group, whichever is earlier.

Additional Alibaba Rights

In addition to the rights discussed above, the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, provides us with certain other rights with respect to Ant Group. These include, among others:

customary information rights;
approval rights over certain Ant Group or Alipay actions;
rights to ensure our ability to participate in any qualified IPO of Ant Group;
approval rights (with the consent of the Independent Committee) over increases to the size of Ant Group board resulting in the number of board seats exceeding a certain specific number; and
approval rights (with the consent of the Independent Committee) over any Alipay IPO.

Pursuant to the 2020 Amendments, the foregoing rights requiring the Independent Committee’s consent will terminate upon the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group. However, pursuant to the 2020 Amendments and the 2022 Amendments, if a qualified IPO of Ant Group has not been completed within the prescribed period of time, these rights will no longer be subject to termination upon the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group. For more information, see “— Termination of Alibaba Rights” below.

Termination of Alibaba Rights

Under the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, certain of our rights with respect to Ant Group were terminated upon our receipt of the Issuance.

192

In addition, the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, provides that, in connection with Ant Group or Alipay commencing an IPO process, we and Ant Group will discuss in good faith the amendment or termination of our rights to the extent necessary or advisable to achieve an efficient and successful IPO. Certain of our rights that would be incremental to the rights of other shareholders of Ant Group as of the consummation of the IPO (excluding, among other things, our information rights) will terminate if required by a relevant stock exchange or governmental authority, or if necessary to obtain a legal opinion in connection with the IPO application. If the IPO application is withdrawn or rejected by the relevant authorities, or if the IPO is not consummated within a certain period of time, then any of our rights that were terminated or amended in anticipation of the IPO will be restored.

Pursuant to the 2020 Amendments, the following rights under the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, will terminate upon the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group:

our rights to participate in any qualified IPO of Ant Group or Alipay;
the Independent Committee’s approval rights over:
voluntary transfers of any equity securities of Alipay;
increases to the size of Ant Group board resulting in the number of board seats exceeding a certain number; and
any Alipay IPO.

If the IPO of Ant Group has not been completed within the prescribed period of time, it is expected that the foregoing Independent Committee’s approval rights will, pursuant to the 2020 Amendments and the 2022 Amendments, no longer be subject to termination upon the completion of a qualified IPO of Ant Group.

Alipay Commercial Agreement

Under the Alipay commercial agreement among us, Alipay and Ant Group, which agreement still remains in place following the 2014 restructuring and the 2018, 2019, 2020 and 2022 amendments to our agreements with Ant Group, each as described above, Alipay provides payment processing and escrow services to us. These services enable settlement of transactions on our marketplaces through a secure payment platform and escrow process. Given the significant transaction volume on our platforms, we pay Alipay a fee for these services on terms that are preferential to us. These preferential terms enable us, with certain exceptions, to make available basic payment processing and escrow services to consumers and merchants on our marketplaces free of charge. We believe that these services provide us with a competitive advantage that otherwise would be diminished without the preferential terms of the Alipay commercial agreement.

The fees that we pay Alipay are based on fee rates and actual payment volumes processed on our marketplaces. The fee rates reflect, among other things, Alipay’s bank-processing costs and operating costs allocable to the services provided to us, and accordingly are subject to adjustment on an annual basis to the extent these costs increase or decline. In connection with the 2014 restructuring, the Alipay commercial agreement was amended to provide that a special independent committee formed by our independent directors and the director designated by SoftBank, or the Independent Committee, must approve the fee rates in advance on an annual basis. The fee rates for the immediately preceding year remain in effect until such time as the annual approval by the Independent Committee has been obtained. In fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, service fees in connection with the payment services provided by Alipay under this agreement amounted to RMB8,723 million, RMB10,598 million and RMB11,824 million (US$1,865 million), respectively. The Alipay commercial agreement has an initial term of 50 years, and is automatically renewable for further periods of 50 years, subject to our right to terminate at any time upon one year’s prior written notice. Prior to the 2020 Amendments, if the Alipay commercial agreement was required by applicable regulatory authorities, including under stock exchange listing rules, to be modified in certain circumstances, a one-time payment may have been payable to us by Ant Group to compensate us for the impact of the adjustment. Certain conforming amendments were made to the Alipay commercial agreement as part of the relevant amendments to our agreements with Ant Group and Alipay described above. Pursuant to the 2020 Amendments, we no longer have the right to receive such one-time payment. This change was made to facilitate the IPO of Ant Group. If the IPO of Ant Group is withdrawn or rejected by governmental authority or is not completed within a certain period of time, the change will be unwound and our right will be restored.

193

Pursuant to the 2022 Amendments, our right to such one-time payment will no longer be restored. We have considered the probability of such one-time payment becoming payable, the changes in the regulatory and operational environment of our and Ant Group’s businesses and the resultant uncertainty to the two businesses if Ant Group were to remain subject to the obligation to make such one-time payment. We believe that an amendment to the Alipay commercial agreement to remove Ant Group’s obligation to pay such one-time payment will ultimately enhance the economic benefit that we may receive from Ant Group as a result of our equity interest in Ant Group and help us better manage related party and other risks arising from changes in the regulatory and operational environment.

Pursuant to the 2022 Amendments, from August 13, 2023, with respect to any payment processing and escrow services to be provided by Ant Group to us outside of Mainland China, the fee rates and payment-related terms for such services will no longer be governed by the Alipay commercial agreement and will instead be agreed upon between Ant Group and us separately.

Ancillary Agreements

In connection with our entry into the original SAPA in 2014, we also entered into the 2014 IPLA, a data sharing agreement, an amended and restated shared services agreement, a SME loan cooperation framework agreement and a trademark agreement, each of which is described below. On July 25, 2022, we and Ant Group agreed to terminate the data sharing agreement. It is intended that we and Ant Group will, to the extent necessary for each party to provide services to our respective customers, instead negotiate the terms of data sharing arrangements on a case-by-case basis and as permitted by applicable laws and regulations.

Pursuant to the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, upon the Issuance we also entered into the Amended IPLA, a cross license agreement and various intellectual property transfer agreements in connection with, and to implement, the contemplated intellectual property and asset transfers described in “— Issuance of Equity Interest” above.

Alipay Intellectual Property License and Software Technology Services Agreement

2014 IPLA

Pursuant to the original 2011 framework agreement, we entered into the 2011 IPLA, pursuant to which we and our subsidiaries licensed to Alipay certain intellectual property rights and provided various software technology services to Alipay and its subsidiaries. In August 2014, we entered into the 2014 IPLA.

Under the 2011 IPLA, Alipay paid us a royalty and software technology services fee equal to the sum of an expense reimbursement plus 49.9% of the consolidated pre-tax income of Alipay and its subsidiaries until a liquidity event of Alipay or Ant Group. The calculation of the profit share percentage was subject to downward adjustments upon certain dilutive equity issuances by Alipay or Ant Group. Under the 2014 IPLA, we received, in addition to a software technology service fee, royalty streams related to Alipay and other current and future businesses of Ant Group, which we refer to collectively as the profit share payments. The profit share payments were paid at least annually and equal the sum of an expense reimbursement plus 37.5% of the consolidated pre-tax income of Ant Group (subject to certain adjustments), including not only Alipay but all of Ant Group’s subsidiaries.

In fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, under the 2014 IPLA, we recognized royalty and software technology services fees, net of costs incurred by us, amounting to RMB3,835 million, nil and nil, respectively, as other income, and the relevant expense reimbursement amounted to nil, nil and nil, respectively, over the same periods.

Upon our receipt of the Issuance in September 2019, we entered into the Amended IPLA and terminated the 2014 IPLA, and accordingly, the profit share payment arrangement under the 2014 IPLA automatically terminated.

Amended IPLA

Pursuant to the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019, we, Ant Group and Alipay entered into the Amended IPLA upon our receipt of the Issuance, at which time we also transferred certain intellectual property and assets to Ant Group and its subsidiaries and the profit share payment arrangement was terminated, as described in “— Issuance of Equity Interest” above.

While the profit share payments have terminated under the Amended IPLA, Ant Group may in certain circumstances continue to make certain royalty payments to us (as agreed to by Ant Group and the Independent Committee), which may be used as pre-emptive rights funded payments under the SAPA, as described in “— Pre-emptive Rights” above.

194

Additionally, pursuant to the Amended IPLA, Ant Group and its subsidiaries will receive expanded rights to apply for, register and manage certain intellectual property related to their businesses, subject to certain continuing restrictions and our rights, and we will cease to provide certain software technology services to Ant Group and its subsidiaries.

The Amended IPLA will terminate upon the earliest of:

the full payment of all pre-emptive rights funded payments under the SAPA;
the closing of a qualified IPO of Ant Group or Alipay; and
our transfer to Ant Group of any remaining intellectual property we own that is exclusively related to the business of Ant Group.

SME Loan Cooperation Framework Agreement

We and Ant Group entered into a SME loan cooperation framework agreement in August 2014, pursuant to which each party agreed to cooperate with, and provide certain services with respect to, the other party’s enforcement of certain rights of the other party against users of its platforms and services and with respect to the provision of certain financial services to our customers and merchants. In particular, we agreed, upon Ant Group’s request, to close down or suspend online storefronts and restrict marketing activities on our platforms of persons defaulting on loans made by Ant Group and persons in violation of Alipay rules and regulations, and to publish notices on our platforms and provide information regarding these persons, in each case in a manner to be further agreed upon from time to time. Ant Group agreed, upon our request, to make loans and/or extensions of credit and related financial services available to our users, freeze and pay over to us funds in accounts of users violating our rules and regulations or agreements with us, accelerate loans and terminate credit facilities of these users, restrict marketing activities on its platforms by these users, and provide information regarding these users, in each case in a manner to be further agreed upon from time to time. Neither party is required to pay any fees in consideration for the services provided by the other party, and apart from the provision of these services, there will be no other exchange of value in connection with this agreement. The cooperation agreement has an initial term of five years, with automatic renewals upon expiry for additional five-year periods.

From time to time, we expect to enter into similar commercial arrangements with respect to cooperation matters and the provision of services between us and Ant Group and to our respective customers.

Trademark Agreement

We and Ant Group entered into a trademark agreement in August 2014, pursuant to which we granted Ant Group a non-transferable, non-assignable and non-sublicensable (except to its subsidiaries) license for it and its sublicensed subsidiaries to continue to use certain trademarks and domain names based on trademarks owned by us, in connection with their payment services business and the SME loan business transferred by us to them, and in the same manner of use as in August 2014, and a non-transferable, non-assignable and non-sublicensable (except to its subsidiaries) license to use other trademarks and domain names based on trademarks owned by us, and in that manner, as we may agree to allow in the future. Pursuant to the trademark agreement, each of the parties further agreed to the rights and limitations that each would have to use the “Ali” name or prefix and the “e-commerce” (and its Chinese equivalent) name, prefix or logo as part of a trademark or domain name in each party’s and its subsidiaries’ respective businesses. Neither party is required to pay any fees under this agreement, and, apart from the licenses and rights set forth in the agreement, there will be no other exchange of value in connection with this agreement. Pursuant to the SAPA, following our receipt of the Issuance, we transferred and are in the process of transferring to Ant Group ownership of several of the trademarks and domain names licensed by us to Ant Group. However, the trademark agreement will remain in effect in accordance with its terms following the transaction to provide for a continued license of other trademarks that we will continue to own.

Shared Services Agreement and Other Commercial Arrangements with Ant Group

We and Ant Group entered into a shared services agreement, which was amended and restated in August 2020 in connection with the 2020 Amendments to the SAPA. Pursuant to the shared services agreement, we and Ant Group provide certain administrative and support services to each other and our respective affiliates. We also provide Ant Group and its affiliates with cloud computing services, marketplace software technology services and other services. See “—Commercial Arrangements with Investees and Ant Group and Its Affiliates.”

195

Agreements Entered into in 2020

Arrangements to Acquire Further Shares in an IPO of Ant Group

In 2020, we entered into certain agreements with Ant Group, pursuant to which we may subscribe for additional shares in Ant Group as part of an IPO of Ant Group, such that we may continue to hold an equity interest not exceeding 33% in Ant Group upon the completion of such IPO of Ant Group.

Documents to Implement Transfers of IP Contemplated by SAPA (As Amended)

In connection with the 2020 Amendments, we entered into a number of agreements pursuant to which we transferred to Ant Group certain intellectual property exclusively relating to the business of Ant Group in connection with the IPO of Ant Group, which transfers were contemplated by the SAPA, as amended in 2018 and 2019. Ant Group would be required to transfer such intellectual property back to us if the IPO of Ant Group is not completed within a certain period of time. Pursuant to the 2022 Amendments, having considered the relevant insignificance of such intellectual property to us and the uncertainties associated with any such requirements to transfer such intellectual property back to us in light of the regulatory and operational changes, we agreed that Ant Group would no longer be required to transfer such intellectual property to us regardless of whether the IPO of Ant Group is completed.

Investments Involving Ant Group

We have invested in businesses in which Ant Group is a shareholder or co-invested with Ant Group in other businesses. For instance, in fiscal year 2020, we, Ant Group and Yunfeng invested in Meinian, a company that is listed on the Shenzhen Stock Exchange and offers health examination, health evaluation, health consulting and other services.

Share-based Award Arrangements

Certain of our employees hold share-based awards granted by Junhan and Ant Group, and certain employees of Ant Group hold share-based awards granted by us. These awards will be settled by respective grantors upon disposal of these awards by the holders, vesting or exercise of these awards, depending on the forms of these awards. In addition, Junhan and Ant Group have the right to repurchase the vested awards (or any underlying equity for the settlement of the vested awards) granted by them, as applicable, from the holders upon an initial public offering of Ant Group or the termination of the holders’ employment with us at a price to be determined based on the then fair market value of Ant Group.

Starting from April 2020, the parties agreed to settle with each other the cost associated with certain share-based awards granted to each other’s employees upon vesting. The settlement amounts under this arrangement will depend on the values of Ant Group share-based awards granted to our employees and our share-based awards granted to employees of Ant Group. It is expected that the net settlement amount would be insignificant to us.

Transactions with Entities Affiliated with Our Directors and Officers

Jack Ma, formerly one of our directors, Joe Tsai, our executive vice chairman, and J. Michael Evans, our president and director, have purchased their own aircraft for both business and personal use. These individuals have waived any leasing fees for the use of such aircraft in connection with the performance of their duties as our directors and executive officers, and we have agreed to assume the cost of maintenance, crew and operation of the aircraft where the cost is allocated for business purposes. Since 2020, we stopped paying any costs for the aircraft of Jack Ma and J. Michael Evans.

Relationship with Investment Funds Affiliated with Jack Ma

Jack Ma currently holds minority interests in the general partners of a number of Yunfeng investment funds, in which he is entitled to receive a portion of carried interest proceeds. We refer to these funds collectively as the Yunfeng Funds. He also holds minority interests in certain investment advisor entities of certain Yunfeng Funds. In addition, Jack Ma, his wife, certain trusts established for the benefit of his family and certain entities controlled by Jack Ma and his wife have committed, or are expected to commit, funds to the general partners or as limited partners of certain Yunfeng Funds.

196

Jack Ma has either non-voting interests or has waived the exercise of his voting power with respect to his interests in each of the investment advisor entities and the managing entities of certain Yunfeng Funds. Jack Ma has also agreed to donate all distributions of (x) carried interest proceeds he may receive in respect of the Yunfeng Funds and (y) dividends he may receive with respect to his holdings of shares in any investment advisor entity of the Yunfeng Funds, which we collectively refer to as the Yunfeng GP Distributions, to, or for the benefit of, the Alibaba Group Charitable Fund or other entities identified by Jack Ma that serve charitable purposes. In addition, Jack Ma has agreed that, other than his income tax obligations arising from recognition of income from Yunfeng GP Distributions, he will not claim any charitable deductions with respect to donations of his Yunfeng GP Distributions against his other income tax obligations. See “— Commitments of Jack Ma to Alibaba Group” below. We believe that, through its expertise, knowledge base and extensive network of contacts in private equity in China, Yunfeng will assist us in developing a range of relevant strategic investment opportunities.

The Yunfeng Funds have historically entered into co-investment transactions with us and third parties. We have also invested in other businesses in which the Yunfeng Funds are shareholders. For instance, in fiscal year 2020, we, Ant Group and Yunfeng invested in Meinian.

Commitments of Jack Ma to Alibaba Group

Jack Ma, formerly one of our directors, has confirmed the following commitments to our board of directors:

He intends to reduce and thereafter limit his direct and indirect economic interest in Ant Group over time (for the avoidance of doubt, other than the equity stake in Ant Group held by our company), to a percentage that does not exceed his and his affiliates’ interest in our company immediately prior to our initial public offering and that the reduction will occur in a manner by which neither Jack Ma nor any of his affiliates would receive any economic benefit;
He will donate all of his Yunfeng GP Distributions to, or for the benefit of, the Alibaba Group Charitable Fund or other entities identified by him that serve charitable purposes;
Other than his income tax obligations arising from recognition of income from Yunfeng GP Distributions, he will not claim any charitable deductions with respect to donations of his Yunfeng GP Distributions against his other income tax obligations; and
If required by us, while he remains an Alibaba executive, he will assume for our benefit legal ownership of investment vehicles, holding companies and variable interest entities that further our business interests in Internet, media and telecom related businesses and, in this case, he will disclaim all economic benefits from his ownership and enter into agreements to transfer any benefits to us (or as we may direct) when permitted by applicable law.

Transactions with Other Investees

We have extended loans to certain of our investees for working capital and other uses in conjunction with our investments. As of March 31, 2022, the aggregate outstanding balance of these loans was RMB3,000 million (US$473 million), with remaining terms of up to four years and interest rates of up to 10% per annum.

We have agreed to provide a guarantee for a term loan facility of HK$7.7 billion (US$1.0 billion) in favor of Cingleot, a company that is partially owned by Cainiao Network, in connection with a logistic center development project at the Hong Kong International Airport. As of the date of this annual report, HK$3,413 million (US$436 million) was drawn down by that entity under this facility.

We have also co-invested with certain of our investees in other businesses. For example, we have made co-investments with Hangzhou Hanyun Xinling Equity Investment Fund Partnership and New Retail Strategic Opportunities Fund, L.P. (both of which are our investees that focus on retail-related businesses) in a number of companies, including Red Star Macalline Group Corporation Limited and Sun Art.

197

Other Commercial Transactions with Investees

Other than the transactions disclosed above, we also have commercial arrangements with certain of our investees and other related parties in which:

we recorded cost and expenses paid to investees for cloud computing services, content acquisition, purchase of inventory and various other services; and
we recorded income generated from investees for providing marketing, commission and other services.

The amounts relating to these services provided and received represent less than 1% of our revenue and total costs and expenses, respectively, for the years ended March 31, 2020, 2021 and 2022.

Contractual Arrangements among Our Subsidiaries, Variable Interest Entities and the Variable Interest Entity Equity Holders

Chinese law restricts foreign ownership in enterprises that provide value-added telecommunications services, which includes the ICPs. As a result, we operate our Internet businesses and other businesses in which foreign investment is restricted or prohibited in China through contractual arrangements between our relevant subsidiaries, the variable interest entities, which, where applicable, hold the ICP licenses and other regulated licenses and generally operate our Internet businesses and other businesses in which foreign investment is restricted or prohibited, and the variable interest entity equity holders. For a description of these contractual arrangements, see “Item 4. Information on the Company — C. Organizational Structure — Contractual Arrangements among Our Subsidiaries, Variable Interest Entities and the Variable Interest Entity Equity Holders.”

Indemnification Agreements

We have entered into indemnification agreements with our directors and executive officers. These agreements require us to indemnify these individuals, to the fullest extent permitted by law, for certain liabilities to which they may become subject as a result of their affiliation with us.

Employment Agreements

See “Item 6. Directors, Senior Management and Employees — B. Compensation — Employment Agreements.”

Share Options

See “Item 6. Directors, Senior Management and Employees — B. Compensation — Equity Incentive Plans.”

C.     Interests of Experts and Counsel

Not applicable.

ITEM 8.    FINANCIAL INFORMATION

A.   Consolidated Statements and Other Financial Information

See “Item 18. Financial Statements.”

198